On Nov. 18, a couple riding a two-wheeler fell into a pit dug up for road work at K.R. Nagar. The man died. His wife is in a critical condition.
A family has been shattered, yet there is no public outrage, no visible accountability, no punishment, no assurance that the hospital bills will be paid. Nothing.
How many deaths before bad roads become a political issue? Not enough, since the Opposition does not protest, nor do taxpayers.
Three years ago, when industrialists in Bengaluru criticised the Government over the city’s terrible roads, then Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar thundered back: “Ask the Centre how much money they have given to Bengaluru, despite Karnataka being the second-highest tax contributor.”
Wah! what a deflection. Except, we Kannadigas have a counter-question: We pay the highest State Road Tax in the country; what are you, Karnataka Government, doing with our money?
Congress, BJP or JD(S) doesn’t matter. None of them build roads to last. Instead, they build roads that need to be rebuilt. No wonder, it is said that the wheels of Indian politics are greased by ‘daambar’.
Perhaps Rahul Gandhi, our CM’s boss, who is ever ready with the Constitution in hand, should remind his party in Karnataka that motorable roads are a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution.
In 2015, the Mumbai High Court said that “in the event any loss is caused due to its violation, the citizens have a right to seek compensation.” Now that compensation, when offered, becomes another spectacle.
The irony is that we, taxpayers, pay for roads. Corruption gives us bad roads. Then, when those roads cause accidents, politicians use our taxpayers’ money to compensate victims and earn publicity! So, we are looted twice: First to make politicians rich and then to make them famous!
Bengaluru alone has spent over Rs. 24,000 crore on roads in the past decade. Yet, Bengaluru has some of the worst roads in the country.
The BJP CM in 2021 promised a road maintenance audit. Where is it? Probably lost in a pothole!
The Congress CM Siddaramaiah audaciously said that by Sept. 20, 2024, Bengaluru will be pothole-free. His CM seat is gone, but potholes remain.
Also, what happened to the Congress’ chest-thumping protest in 2022 about the infamous ‘40% commission’ in road works? They’re in power now. Any action? Nothing. Zero.
Clearly, 40% is too precious to part with.
Asking politicians to fix the pothole problem is like asking a fox to draft poultry farm safety guidelines.
Even the law is stacked against citizens.
In theory, a PWD officer or contractor whose shoddy roadwork causes a fatal accident could face imprisonment under Section 106 of the BNS for causing death by negligence.
In reality, Police book the victims instead!
In 2015, a young man in Bengaluru braked hard to avoid a pothole. The vehicle skidded and his young wife, who was riding pillion, was thrown off the bike and died.
The Police didn’t see the pothole as the problem. Instead, they said, “If the young man was riding at 30 kmph and had not braked suddenly, he wouldn’t have skidded and his wife would not have died.” So, they filed a ‘death due to negligence’ case against the husband!
But what about the negligence of the BBMP? It seems Government services are the only paid services that do not give even a minimum guarantee of service after having collected payment for it! No consumer court for them.
Roads are the arteries of prosperity for a nation. Yet in 79 years, India has not been able to build long-lasting roads.
Now, our CM, in a State that cannot build roads on the ground, is planning to go underground as he plans to build an 18-kilometre tunnel under Bengaluru to ease traffic.
Meanwhile, unnecessary barricades, unscientific speed breakers, badly designed junctions and roads left half-finished have become part of everyday life. We complain, curse and move on.
This reminds one of Frederick Douglass, who said, “Find out just what people will quietly submit to and you have the exact measure of injustice and wrong which will be imposed upon them.”
Since we, the people, are quiet, bad roads have and will continue to be imposed upon us.
Perhaps that is the real problem. We have quietly submitted to bad roads, broken footpaths and public money disappearing into the ground beneath our wheels.
A politician’s road to riches is paved by our silence as they turn our State and nation into a pothole republic.
e-mail: vikram@starofmysore.com
This post was published on November 21, 2026 7:30 pm