Unity, Yes. But Who Will Be The PM?
Columns, Point of View

Unity, Yes. But Who Will Be The PM?

February 6, 2018

By T.J.S. George

Now that the budget has assured Devaloka by 2019, we can return to more mundane things: How the Opposition parties can unite against the BJP. The attempts made by some leaders last week were natural. Given the proliferation of parties that distinguishes our long-suffering democracy, electoral alliances are the only way to put a brake on the BJP’s increasingly aberrant concepts — from writing a whole new constitution to discriminatory orange passports. But dreams are not reality. Our Opposition parties are so inward-looking that it is difficult for them to join hands in any meaningful way. The BJP’s real strength is Opposition disunity.

So it was no surprise that last week’s efforts proved non-starters. CPM leader Sitaram Yechury’s call for an impeachment of the Chief Justice of India proved a bit too radical to get traction. Sonia Gandhi’s “brainstorming” session was an open-ended idea. Sharad Pawar made some concerted moves to float a broad platform: A Republic Day rally in Mumbai to “save the Constitution” and then a get-together of non-BJP leaders in Delhi. In attendance were the Congress, CPM, CPI, the National Conference, JD(U) rebel Sharad Yadav and also Hardik Patel, Jignesh Mevani and Ram Jethmalani.

That such disparate elements could collect under one umbrella was an indication that the parties recognise the importance of uniting against an opponent who freely uses governmental power to its advantage. But their intentions betray them because they are leader-oriented and the leaders are self-oriented. The Pawar initiative, for example, didn’t click when it became clear that what he had in mind was a national alliance with him as the supreme leader, to wit, the Prime Ministerial candidate.

READ ALSO  Should Gods be cheaper than a luxury bungalow, cost less than a wedding? A tale of Emperors

Pawar will inspire no confidence, given the NCP’s record in office. The party’s twin stars, Pawar and Praful Patel, were known as protectors of lobbies. When the poisonous pesticide endosulfan caused widespread and pathetic birth deformities in Kasargod-South Mangalore areas, Food Minister Pawar remained unconcerned, saying that further tests were necessary to prove endosulfan’s culpability. Civil Aviation Minister Praful Patel handled Air-India in such ways that even a Rs. 30,000 crore bailout has been unable to save it. The CAG and the Public Accounts Committee of Parliament had found evidence of doubtful financial decisions in the purchase of 110 aircraft in one go at a cost of Rs. 50,000 crore.

A party led by such men can only be expected to put their interests above the country’s. Hence the rejection of the Pawar move by other parties. The Trinamool Congress indirectly suggested that Mamata Bannerji was the only leader deserving to be an Opposition Prime Ministerial candidate. There are others who swear by Chandrababu Naidu. And yet others by Naveen Patnaik. The Opposition infighting is the BJP’s joy when it is facing trying times. The Shiv Sena has already walked out and Chandrababu Naidu has openly complained about being neglected. The BJP, in a spirit of defiance, is making overtures to Sharad Pawar in Maharashtra and Jaganmohan Reddy, Naidu’s staunchest enemy, in Andhra Pradesh.

It’s a replay of the Kautilya doctrine of Sama, Dana, Bheda, Danda.  Where conciliation and bribes don’t work, it is open to the use of threats and assaults. Was the recent raid on Karnataka Minister D.K. Shivakumar’s premises part of a plan to scare him into joining the BJP? After all, Shivakumar had helped the BJP’s candidate win the Mysuru Parliamentary seat in the last elections. Was there an understanding with Sharad Pawar in the last Gujarat elections? The BJP had become weak with the rise of the Jignesh-Hardik tide and the results showed that seven districts in the State had become BJP-mukt. The party managed to retain power only because the NCP fielded a large number of candidates and thereby split Opposition votes significantly. Perhaps the NCP, too, has reasons to stay on the safe side of the BJP.

READ ALSO  Veteran journalist TJS George chosen for Swadeshabhimani-Kesari Award

A sensible Opposition can indeed find a solution to the leadership problem that is now obstructing their unity. If Rahul Gandhi is too young and too inexperienced, Mamata Bannerji too unpredictable in her moods and Sharad Pawar too tainted, they can still narrow down to someone like Naveen Patnaik who is at least non-controversial although his commitment to meaningful governance is open to doubt. His ability to avoid the limelight is no mean talent. If Rahul Gandhi sees the wisdom of biding his time till 2022 and others see the apparent harmlessness of Patnaik, a united Opposition is not impossible to replace a party that allows lynching to become a patriotic pastime.

[email protected]


ONE COMMENT ON THIS POST To “Unity, Yes. But Who Will Be The PM?”

  1. Raju says:

    Reading this point of view proves that the crooks are a lot more resourceful and united especially when they all lost money from a common enemy! Thus was apost I found which makes absolute sense! Every one of this authors prior columns reeks bias!
    Indians can tolerate
    500 years Muslim rule
    200 years British rule
    60 years Family rule
    10 years Italian lady rule
    But not 3 years of Hindu rule?😬


    If Modi fails in his fight againt corruption and black money, no PM of India will have the courage to take this issue again on his agenda for next 100 years and corrupt politicians, beaurocrates, police, criminals and businessman will keep looting this country as their birth right. So it is the duty of every resposible citizen to stand in support of PM Modi and fail the evil design of corrupt people to incite violence and create anarchy.
    If we fail to do our duty today, our children and grandchildren will never forgive us, will hold us responsible for not giving them a clean India. If you agree, please send this message to all your contacts.
    I am *NOT in Politics* and as of now, I have *no plans to get into Politics*, but there will be people who may consider this post to be Politically motivated. My *Humble apologies in advance.*

    I was wondering why are so many people against our *Honourable Prime Minister Narendra Modi*. I noticed that this started after *Demonetization* and keeping that in mind, I was thinking who could be *people who will be affected by Demonetization*.
    I was shocked to discover that here are following categories of people who will feel the impact more than anyone –
    *1. Educational Institutions* – They used to get all Capitation fee in cash and most of it unaccounted.
    *2. Terrorist Organisation* – Their Funding is under stress
    *3. Fake Currency Dealers* – With stress on Digital Economy, they are under Major Stress
    *4. Real Estate Mafia* – We all know that a Big Part of payment had to be made in Cash and now they find it difficult to account for unaccounted cash
    *5. Hawala Dealers* – With almost all the money in account and a close watch on withdrawals, *they won’t mind killing Modi*
    *6. Fake Trusts and Charities* – They have been used for Money laundering and with the stopping of large donations by cash, they are unable to fulfill their primary agenda
    *7. Politicians* – Less said, better it is. Just look at almost NIL SCAM in last 3+ years is a Proof that many Politicians including BJP members are unhappy with Modi. They expected Modi to be like earlier Prime Ministers and close his eyes.
    *8. Rich Agriculture Land Owners* – With most of the subsidy connected to Bank accounts, they are getting exposed.
    *9. Film industry* – It’s a well known fact that it uses a lot of Black Money and except for Genuine Film makers, others are suffering.
    *10. Sports & Other kind of Betting* – We know that gambling (Except Lottery) is banned and still there was a *turnover of USD 150 Billion*.
    Please understand that *these industries employ some of the Most Brilliant minds* in the country and they will leave no stone unturned to make sure that Modi does not get a second term.
    In this organized effort, even 4 judges appointed by Sonia revolted trying to discredit the Supreme Court Chief Justice
    Now it’s for us, *as responsible citizens, to decide whether we want to support the above 10 Categories of people or to support ourselves*.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending Posts

Mysuru's favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 39 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it's readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.