Why mourn the Queen?
Columns, In Black & White

Why mourn the Queen?

September 17, 2022

The British Queen is dead. She was the representative of one of the most cruel empires. Yet, basic human decency requires us to express our condolences. However, the Indian Government and some Indians went overboard with condolence, making us look subservient.

No matter how much anyone attempts to soften the evil image of the British Empire via the imagery of the ever-so-pleasant Queen Elizabeth II, the fact remains that the British Empire was not a force for good.

 If you happen to read ‘Legacy of Violence: A History of the British Empire’ by Pulitzer-winning history Professor Caroline Elkins or Shashi Tharoor’s ‘An Era of Darkness: The British Empire in India’ you will get a glimpse of the havoc the British wreaked on the Indian subcontinent and its other colonies. The essay series by Economist Utsa Patnaik lays bare the economic loot of India by the Empire.

That said, any self-respecting Indian would cringe seeing how our Government mourned the British Queen.

The Indian Government declared September 11 as ‘State Mourning’ throughout India, and an official statement said that this was done as ‘a mark of respect to Her Majesty’.

 Article 18 of the Indian Constitution abolishes titles such as Maharaja, Highness, Majesty, etc. Why, then, does the Indian Government, in its official statement, feel the need to address the Queen as ‘Her Majesty’? She is the Britishers’ Majesty. We don’t have it in independent India.

Well, one must admit that even the Indian media and educated Indians, while addressing former members of princely Indian families, words like ‘Your Highness’ and ‘Majesty’ often creep up. 

On Sunday, the Indian flag was lowered to half-mast at the Red Fort and Rashtrapati Bhavan. And if India declaring a state of mourning for the British Queen wasn’t embarrassing enough, the illumination of the Mysore Palace too was cancelled that day!

 The BJP Government deploys words like “swadeshi”, “swaraj” and “swabhiman” to claim a monopoly over patriotism.

This Government loves to change the anglicised names of our cities; another effort to erase the remnants of British rule. But now, without hesitation, it declares “State mourning” for the head of an empire that unapologetically distorted the names of our cities repeatedly.

READ ALSO  Scroll less... Sleep more

 Last week, Prime Minister Narendra Modi, while renaming Kingsway (named after King George V, Queen Elizabeth’s grandfather) to Kartavya Path, called the old name a “symbol of slavery”.

 Earlier this month, during the commissioning of India’s first indigenously built aircraft carrier INS Vikrant, the Prime Minister also unveiled a new Navy ensign, Nishaan, replacing the Colonial Saint George’s Cross. After unveiling the new ensign, the PM said the country has now taken off a “burden of slavery.”

Now, just a few days after speaking about shedding symbols of slavery and installing a statue of Subash Chandra Bose, the man who wanted to wage war on the British Empire to free us, this Government declares “State mourning” for a British Queen! It’s bewildering.

The Prime Minister said, “I believe we should respect the dead and that despite all the horrible past of colonisation and other human rights violations, the Queen deserves a dignified final adieu.”  Yes, the dead deserve a dignified farewell, and Heads of State, as per protocol, can express their condolence, but why should this nation and its people officially mourn her death?

Some say let’s mourn the Queen, not the Empire. But without the Empire, she wouldn’t be Queen. So whether we like it or not, she is the head of the British Empire, a head who never once apologised for the sins of her fathers.

When Queen Elizabeth II came to India in 1997, everyone thought she would apologise for the atrocities committed in India.

All she said was, “It is no secret that there have been some difficult episodes in our past — Jallianwala Bagh, which I shall visit tomorrow, is a distressing example. But history cannot be rewritten, however much we might sometimes wish otherwise.”

 Indeed, history cannot be rewritten, but an apology is a way to acknowledge that what happened should never have happened. So, why didn’t she apologise? Money issues — reparations.

READ ALSO  Mysuru Chocolate !

The proof of this came when the then UK Foreign Office Minister Mark Field said, “There may well be financial implications to making an apology.”

 Worse is what happened after she visited Jallianwala Bagh memorial. On the way out, Prince Philip, her husband, stopped to query an official.

It seems he did not believe India’s claim about the number of people murdered at Jallianwala Bagh. He asked: “Two thousand? It wasn’t, was it? That’s wrong. I was in the navy with Dyer’s son (Col. Reginald Dyer ordered the firing at Jallianwala Bagh). That’s a bit exaggerated…it must include the wounded.”

That’s how insensitive the British Monarchy is about its atrocities. And the Government declares a State mourning for the Head of that Monarchy? And our President is going to her funeral too! Why? 

When most young Britishers, who should be grateful to their Monarchy for the loot and pillage that has kept their cold little Island wealthy, don’t particularly care for them, why should India? In fact, the present Prime Minister of England Liz Truss had said, “I am not against any of them (the royals), I am against the idea that people can be born to rule… I think it is disgraceful.”

Have we forgotten the atrocities the British heaped on us — from killing millions over 200 years — starvation and famines, partition, slave trading, hanging and rampant shootings?

It’s been 75 years; we’re old enough to stand up to the world’s Empires and strong enough to treat them with a sense of indifference when necessary.

 We need to wake up from our subservient slumber, for if we don’t respect ourselves, others don’t have a reason to. As Gandhiji said, “…every man or woman, however weak in body, is the guardian of his or her self-respect and liberty.”

e-mail: [email protected]

8 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Why mourn the Queen?”

  1. Joseph Mundassery says:

    Hello Vikram
    Poor quality article.
    No one asked India to mourn the Queen. Recently over 75,000 Indian techies gained work visas in the UK, and escaped from India. Over 200, 000 Indian students go to the UK to study in its universities, although India has more than 1000 universities. Indians want to escape
    corrupt India through ANY MEANS POSSIBLE.
    Indian doctors UK, refusing to home. Indian students who dropped out of UK universities numbering at least 150,000 do not want to go home and prefer to remain illegal immigrants working in the black economy in the UK developed by Indian businessmen. PM Modi does not want to take them back.
    No need to mourn, but mourn about the ways India has become, corrupt politicians, 40% slice of contracts, institutionally corrupt and society massively corrupt MOURN ABIOUT THIS AFTER 75 YEARS OF INDEPNDENCE.

  2. Howdy, Modi! says:

    India has its Queen-Sonia Gandhi, the Italian bar maid Rajeev Gandhi met after dropping out of Cambridge university-he was a dullard, in a bar in England where Sonia was looking for an English husband!
    Queen Sonia Gandhi ruled India, after her husband died, through her puppet PMs- Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh.
    Queen Sonia Gandhi ensured that JD(S) Kumaraswamy became the Karnataka CM, and ordered Siddu and Congress to work with him.
    Queen Sonia Gandhi,to who, Siddaramaiah , the ex-PM not only bows his head, but crawls on the floor.
    Not satisfied with the medical treatment she received in New Delhi, Queen Sonia Gandhi, has been to England for treatment!! Modi’s government no doubt paid for this treatment!!
    India has its own Italian Queen! Jai Hind!!

  3. Magadi Kempegowda says:

    Sashi Tharoor? Oh, the Malayalee who Mr Ganapathy admires, and who escaped the charge of responsible to his wife’s death through legal technicalities.
    Sashi Tharoor, the PR man of the dreadful UN Secretary General Kofi Annan, mishandled all his appearances in the media, antagonised all the permanent members of the security so much, that when he thought he was of the quality to become the UN Secretary General, and stood for that election. The US, sent him a message that they will veto his candidature, he withdrew . He would have been defeated as he was just aloud mouth .
    Only Vikram and his father Ganapathy appreciate his books, which are full of myths, and hyperboles.
    No one in the Congress wants him as the leader. Certainly not Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi.

  4. Joseph Mundassery says:

    Correction: Indian doctors going to the UK, after failing the knowledge exams, refuse to home

  5. Joseph Mundassery says:

    Correction: Indian doctors going to the UK, after failing the knowledge exams, refuse to home

  6. duplicate howdi modi says:

    She is dead, and some mourned her death and some did not. Move on. Write an article about atrocities meted by Indian politicians, Corrupted officials, greedy businessmen to the nation after independence.
    Our beloved one man with many names writing from far off land thinks India is corrupt..

  7. Howdy, Modi! says:

    @duplicate
    That is your worth-a fake person, no originality and badly educated.
    Keep worshipping your Queen Sonia Gandhi.

  8. Mann Ki Baat! says:

    Hello duplicate howdi Modi
    If you are a duplicate, then you have the same bad characteristics of the original Howdy Modi who you accuse. Duplicate means copy of the original, example: a duplicate key.
    I agree you are a dullard and needs more education, if you have something called the brain.

ABOUT

Mysuru’s favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 41 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it’s readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.

CONTACT

Academy News Papers Private Limited, Publishers, Star of Mysore & Mysuru Mithra, 15-C, Industrial ‘A’ Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru-570015. Phone no. – 0821 249 6520

To advertise on Star of Mysore, email us at

Online Edition: [email protected]
Print Editon: [email protected]
For News/Press Release: [email protected]