Has Modi found Final Solution to Kashmir ?
Abracadabra By K. B. Ganapathy, Columns

Has Modi found Final Solution to Kashmir ?

August 9, 2019

Do we need a Holocaust Museum?

The morning of Monday, 5th August, 2019 will be remembered as the Red Letter Day, as the historic day of Independent India. If you wonder why, the answer is in the historic decision taken by the BJP-NDA Narendra Modi Government on that Monday morning in the Rajya Sabha. That was the morning when the Modi Government finished the unfinished job of Aug. 15, 1947 partition of India into Muslim Pakistan and Secular India. 

This responsibility of securing to divided new India and its people what is their due — under the Constitution of India, namely, Democracy, Secularism and Equality — irrespective of religion or region, has always been the burden of the Government in power. Sadly, with regard to J&K, this responsibility was never discharged by successive Governments since Independence, though 72 long years have passed into the dark recess of history. Even Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s BJP-NDA Government was, sadly, a mirror image of the earlier Congress Governments.

J&K has always been given a special status under the Temporary Provision of Article 370 and Article 35A for the reason that it was a Muslim majority State. Nobody seems to have realised that in a Secular India the question of religious majority and minority status of a State does not find validity under the Constitution. But an exception was made under the Temporary Provision of Article 370 which the successive rulers took political and financial advantage treating it as sacrosanct. Instead of annulling it for the sake of unity and integrity of India, successive Union Governments turned a Nelson’s eye on it. 

This Temporary Article 370 and also Article 35A, in fact, were the weakest links in the chain of Articles our Constitution is made of. Has it not been said that the strength of a chain lies in its weakest link? Now that these two weak links have been removed, the Constitution is doubly strengthened. For the first time, I personally feel I am living in a United India after it was truncated in 1947. 

Muslim ‘leaders’ in Kashmir were making all kinds of demands like more autonomy, independence and a section wanting to accede to Pakistan. All because there is Muslim majority. Can the majority Hindus in other States claim preferential treatment over the minority Muslims on the same skewed logic?  Sadly, when the Hindu Kashmiris in the Valley were driven away by the Muslim militants neither the successive Central Governments nor the State Governments could do anything to keep them in their own land of birth. 

Be that as it may, I am musing on this issue because of the increase in the number of messages I started getting on the social media. Last evening, I received a forwarded WhatsApp video link which the sender wanted me to watch and listen. The headline itself was quite loaded I thought — ‘Confessions of the last Indian Hindu.’ It was by Shefali Vaidya delivered sometime in 2017 but put to circulation probably now for its topicality in view of the abrogation. She is quite articulate in her harangue in English and the subject was about how Hindus were treated by Muslims,  sometimes with a little help from the fellow Hindus, in different parts of the country and at different times of history. A few examples may suffice to understand her feelings about the way her own people, Goud Saraswat Brahmins (GSB) and other Hindus were treated for centuries past by the Muslim rulers. 

READ ALSO  Rahul, the young man in a hurry to become Prime Minister and the Perils

As we know, GSBs claim their roots, as a racial people, to Kashmir Valley. But, following Muslim occupation they were given three options  — of converting to Islam or to get killed or to leave the Valley. Naturally, majority of them decided to leave their hearth and home and moved Southwards. She then talks of how after 1947, Kashmiri Hindus were forced to flee likewise and the successive Governments didn’t do anything saying it was Kashmir’s problem.

She then talks of Tipu Sultan, whose birthday is being celebrated in Karnataka since 2013 when Siddharamaiah became the Chief Minister saying he was a great patriot when majority of people considered him a tyrant who indulged in conversion and loot. But, Hindus in other parts of India thought it was not their problem, that it was Karnataka’s problem! 

She also talks of ‘Love Jihad.’ When in West Bengal the immersion connected with Durga Puja was banned, Hindus felt it was a Bengal problem and didn’t protest. 

When 40,000 Rohingya Muslims were driven out of Myanmar and settled in India, Hindus did not object saying it was not their problem. So, according to her, Hindus did not protest when injustice or violence was meted out to Hindus living in different States or groups saying it was not their problem.   

Listening to her video, I thought her inspiration for that kind of narration came from a book written by a Jew which I happened to read many years ago and dealt with the same problem that she mentions about Hindus. I quote the text from the scrap book I have maintained:

First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out — because I was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out — because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out —because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me — and there was no one left to speak for me.

— Martin Niemöller

Having said this, the most purposeful suggestion that came from Shefali Vaidya relates to a Museum to be set up to commemorate what she calls the Hindu Holocaust. Probably, she got inspiration from Meenakshi Lekhi, a senior Supreme Court Advocate and BJP MP, who had tweeted on June 28, 2018 as follows: 

“Holocaust Museum in Berlin to remind people of such dangers for all times to come. Wish we had a similar Museum in Delhi to remind people about the sins of Emergency. Which saw breakdown of Constitution, murders, nasbandis, jailing political opponents…NEVER AGAIN.”

According to Shefali Vaidya, we (read Hindus) need a Museum like this to honour the Hindu Holocaust. Documenting every case of Hindu genocide from the skull tower of Khilji to Aurangzeb excesses, to the Goan Inquisition….to the partition slaughter to the Kashmiri Pandits’ exodus. 

FIELD OF STELAE: Holocaust Memorial at Berlin.

This takes me to my own visit to the unique Holocaust Museum and Memorial in Berlin (see pic. above), Germany, in the year 2017. I think, reproducing what I had written in my Abracadabra dated Oct.26, 2017 will be eloquent enough to express my feeling and opinion: 

We took a drop at the Holocaust Museum and the Memorial to the murdered Jews of Europe — a unique Memorial known as Field of Stelae (an upright stone slab). It is like a maze. There are 13 pathways which are wheelchair-accessible. The books, literature, cinemas about Holocaust and the persecution of Jews during Hitler’s rule were mostly written and produced by Jews, a race very intelligent and creative. Naturally, there could be exaggeration, I thought. However, after visiting Dachau in Munich I changed my opinion. About it later.

The World War II and the German Government’s conduct towards its own citizens under Hitler, specially the minorities — Jews, Sintas and Roma — and the way they were persecuted should be a lesson to all the Governments across the world. I was wondering why in Hitler’s scheme of persecuting minorities, Muslims were not mentioned. Could be, their number was minuscule and presence negligible. Could be also for the reason Turkey remained (wisely) neutral between both the Axis and the Allies until it saw victory for Allies and (again wisely) joined the Allies in      February 1945, just before the war ended. Good. May be, that is the reason Muslims don’t figure in the evil design of Hitler like what he did to the Jews.

Jews were persecuted in every way possible, apart from Hitler’s “final solution” for Jewish problem (if it was a problem at all). For example, from 1st April 1933, Jewish shops should not be entered by Germans by race. Hitler’s private force called SA would put up posters: “Germans do not buy from Jews.” Or “Germans buy only at German shops.” Germans abroad were also asked to boycott Jewish shops. The Jewish manufacturing companies were also threatened. However, bread is more important for a human being than pride. The campaign was stopped when it was found people did not take part in the boycott.”

It never occurred to me even after seeing the Jewish Holocaust Museum and Memorial in Berlin that Hindus of India too will need one such Museum, considering the human massacre and the holocaust Hindus in India had suffered over centuries till we got Independence in 1947. Now, after reading Meenakshi Lekhi’s tweet and watching Shefali Vaidya’s video, I guess they have a point.

e-mail: [email protected]

10 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Has Modi found Final Solution to Kashmir ?”

  1. boregowda says:

    We Hindus are most passive (like cows) and indifferent. You have rightly said that there is zero unity and feeling for our neighbors. This is why we let Muslim and British invaders loot our wealth and rule us over centuries. We have to break our slave mentality be more assertive, bold and unite to fight for justice and peace all across India and beyond.

    • Vipra says:

      You are missing the most important reason why history played out the way it did

      Hinduism was never a single religion . It is collect of thousands of different castes ,built solely upon the guy on the higher rungs of caste pyramid oppressing the guys at the bottom

      So why would anyone from the oppressed casts fight for such a f… cked up system

      One of my Dalit friends said they would rather do namaaz that do Uruluseve

    • Vipra says:

      You are missing the most important reason why history played out the way it did

      Hinduism was never a single religion . It is collect of thousands of different castes ,built solely upon the guy on the higher rungs of caste pyramid oppressing the guys at the bottom
      So why would anyone from the oppressed casts fight for such a f… cked up system
      One of my Dalit friends said they would rather do namaaz that do Uruluseve

  2. Shefali Duggal says:

    Very nice and well written article! Some of my close family members were butchered in Kashmir and some scoundrels in Congress who did not even acknowledge those atrocities for all these years, today defending the article 370 calling Kashmir a concentration camp ! Compared to what our relatives went through, probably Hitler was merciful
    What Modi did today, previous government’s could have done long ago, but they were hung up on minority votebank so much, criminals could get away with murder! They keep saying terrorism has no religion! But, the Congress government had created such an environment that if you commit a crime, it was easy to convert to Islam and you will be free!obviously, hardcore criminals took shelter under Islam to get the government protection!

  3. Halli Haida says:

    @boregowda, you are correct. I have read in these very columns, “Secular” congress supporting Hindus attacking fellow Hindus. Don’t be surprised if you get attacked by these people.

  4. Bhamy V Shenoy says:

    you have raised an interesting but a controversial issue. What holocaust has done to jews by Hitler and his followers, Muslim rulers have done to followers of different religions in several countries of the world. Christians have also done similar things but not the way Muslins have done.
    In secular India if any idea is suggested to build a museum like the one you saw in Berlin (there are such museums but not on that magnitude in other countries) there will be opposition and court cases. However we can suggest constructing a museum where we can show how in the name of religions people have been persecuted or even murdered in different parts of the world but emphasizing how such persecution had taken place in India. We need to show how the so called upper castes treated lower castes in India.
    Such a museum will really show the real secular face of India. It is not likely to be easy to develop one. It will be controversial. How should “atrocities” of Tippu Sultan be exhibited? Will there be even questions raised about Aurangzeb? When photos of temples razed to the ground are shown will there be objections? When systematic disfiguring of statues by Muslims are shown will there be people asking why we are doing it? There will always be pros and cons of doing any thing in this world. However when we see the project from different view points, such a museum will bring about better understanding between people of different faiths. When I have visited such museums, like you discussed I was thinking how we need to avoid such situations in the future rather than thinking of taking “revenge”. While an article like you is certainly helpful in planting seeds, we need a movement.

  5. strangeworld says:

    “Secular India” says @Barmy! Laughable when Muslims in India are recognised with a special status by the state because of their Islamic religion, and are granted special personal laws which Hindus do not have. India does not need holocaust museum, but the repeal of these personal laws, so that All citizens irrespective of their religions have the same laws. Kannadigas should be ashamed when that Muslim fanatic and dictator who tyrannically imprisoned a Hindu king and rule. I am referring to Tipu Sultan, who was a Muslim thug. Shame on all of you, Kannadigas to celebrate his so called Jayanthi and refer to him as some one who fought for independence under British Raj. The fool Kovind, Indian president praised Tipu Sultan as the fighter for independence of India. Fools all of you.
    J and K says the UN,is a disputed territory after Nehru approached the UN. This status of J and K has not gone away.

  6. Dr.A.V.Balakrishna says:

    At the end of the day it is Divide and Rule for Vote Bank. The objective is to stay in power, enjoy the status, keep people in tantrum ,confusion and fear ,suppress ,exploit, terrorize and make an international issue something like issues pertaining to individual house seeking sympathy by outside members. These ideologies are fast loosing ground the world over and sooner it would collapse. People integrated must decide and dictate what they wish to be as citizens within a great country but not left to politician to play upon them.An era has come to an end illustrating Indian Holocaust.

    Kudos to Shri Narendra Modiji ,our Indian Prime Minister and Shri. Amit Shah who go into annals in history of the greatest democracy in world to prove how real democracy function without compromising the nation and its people to ensure equal opportunity and growth to all of its citizens not to few within a dynasty rule.
    For India and rest of the world better days are ahead, rest assured as along as people within the power do not establish their own dynasties and make a fortune out of. Cleansing had been a different task for the PM, but messing up again could be easy so better be watchful at all levels to ensure check and balances which is the hall mark of any democracy. The new blood of young Parliamentarians are cognizant of this for their own India and its future. There is hope now since money and existence is not the primary ideals but the vision and mission ahead. Earlier elections and democracy was a tool to make money fooling people by the virtue of a good speech and oration to blind people. Not any more. History and events that followed has proven that to be false and ineffective way to lead. People both see and hear now and then act judiciously.
    Jai Hind for India. True prayers for all sections of religion to live with peace, harmony and joy with focus to advancement and growth to nation to make it a role model for the rest of the world. Indians have always led in past centuries not after independence of 1947 but continue to lead for ever in future.

  7. Vipra says:

    Yeah !

    Chief minister Yediyurappa is already going around a begging bowl for flood relief
    But no , we will spend all the money on fighter planes, tanks , missiles and whatnot
    We as nation are f..cking ourselves ten times just to screw Pakistan once

    Mera Bharat Mahan

  8. What a World! says:

    @AV Balakrishna What a load of nonsense you have posted! There is muddled thinking right through your post! Modi and his friends are after all politicians,and they carry out any diversion to set talking points away from the real problems facing the country. This J and K business is the recent diversionary tactics,as it changes nothing about the international status of J and K,as UN puts it,a disputed territory. It adds more security head aches as a poster puts in ,as terrorists from there who were hitherto operating in that region can freely travel to other states in India and operate. What a mess Indians create in the name of solving a problem by introducing a greater problem!!

ABOUT

Mysuru's favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 39 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it's readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.