Accidental Chief Minister must not present bogy budget
Abracadabra By K. B. Ganapathy, Columns

Accidental Chief Minister must not present bogy budget

July 9, 2018

A budget, in simple terms, is a statement presented by the government (here Finance Minister) to the State Assembly or the Parliament outlining the government’s probable expenditure for the ensuing financial year and the revenue needed to meet this expenditure. This includes proposed taxes to raise this money.

Karnataka’s coalition government of JD(S) and Congress presented the budget for 2018-19 on July 5, 2018. The Chief Minister H.D. Kumaraswamy, being the Finance Minister also, submitted his own budget of Rs. 2,13,734 crore, refusing the request of Siddharamaiah to accept his budget submitted in Feb. 2018 for Rs. 2,09,181 crore and continue his projects and programmes. Since the elections happened in May 2018 the new Assembly, by not accepting Siddharamaiah’s budget, as mandated passed the vote on account for three months. Now it is for the new government to follow its new budget.

The question is how good or bad this H.D. Kumaraswamy budget is? It is a curate’s egg, say some budget pundits.

Last five years of Siddharamaiah government had neither economic direction nor healthy social purpose. Its objective was to appropriate available funds for building the vote bank for Congress party. So it doled out free or subsidised food items to the BPL and APL card holders and indulged in pampering the minorities, to the exclusion of the upper caste Hindus. For example, Tipu Jayanti was imposed on an unwilling majority. An effort was made to divide a harmonious brotherhood of Veerashaiva-Lingayat religion. In retrospect, I can say, Siddharamaiah, who got 78 seats in this election, would have got the needed 113 seats but for these unwise decisions.

Looking at the way Siddharamaiah went about his so-called egalitarian, social welfare schemes of grants and subsidies, it seems that in the long run it would adversely affect the economic development of our State.

I am reminded of what an American Journalist wrote about the Economic Incentives the US government had introduced to help the poor. He said, “We were just beginning to create the now famous Economic Incentives for husbands to desert their wives, for women to have children without husbands and for all sorts of healthy people to not work.” This was the comment on US Programme of Aid to families with dependant children. Let it be. It is axiomatic that any programme that would make any section of the people lazy is not good for the faster development of a country.

READ ALSO  CM’s public contact programme only on Saturdays

We understand that for H.D. Kumaraswamy, an accidental Chief Minister, it is pay-back time. In fact his election promise of “farmers’ loan waiver within 24 hours of his coming to power” turned out to be an albatross round his neck. He could not deliver this election promise in its totality though managed it partially.

Unfortunately, his budget has exposed him as being partial to the four districts — Ramanagara, Mandya, Mysuru and Hassan — from where he got majority of his 38 seats. This approach to governance goes against the sacred oath he has taken as Chief Minister. But rarely these rulers abide by the spirit and intent of the oath. Kumaraswamy can’t be an exception.

Now look at some of the budget allocation for projects and schemes. The Hale Unduvadi drinking water project, 4 kms up the KRS backwaters. The advantage is that water can be brought to city and 92 villages around it through gravity saving on pumping. The main pumping station needs 80 acres of land but this land has already been sold by the (greedy or corrupt) KIADB to a realtor and property developer, knowing that MUDA had already proposed a drinking water project here and it would need land. HDK’s budget provides Rs. 50 crore. A joke indeed. If the sale of this land is annulled, the compensation to be paid will be more than Rs. 50 crore. Alternatively, the government may ask the purchaser to agree for an alternative land. All this exercise will surely delay the project to the point of abandoning it thus giving advantage to the purchaser! And that is what the corrupt in the government want. Thirst for bribe takes precedence over the thirst for drinking water.

By the way, the original estimated cost was Rs. 327 crore and this Rs. 50 crore seems, in the opinion of a politician, a mere expression of this government’s intent, nothing more !

READ ALSO  Beyond the Lines into Eternity: A Tribute to Kuldip Nayar

Now, consider the number of Universities proposed in the budget and for what disciplines? Film University, Sports and Body Building University, Homeland Security University, Tourism University etc. What about Kite Flying University? Making a mockery of the word and meaning of a University. All these disciplines could be taught as a designated department under the existing Universities. Like the  Fine Arts College (ಲಲಿತ ಕಲೆಗಳ ಕಾಲೇಜು)  where music, dance, drama are taught under the Mysore University. The Medical and Engineering Universities must inevitably be excluded. At a time the government is facing a financial resource crunch, unable even to appoint lecturers, why this kind of wasteful investment. I request our readers to drive or walk around the vast area of Manasagangothri where many new and old buildings are abandoned like ghost houses.

Now talk of creating a Disneyland at Brindavan Gardens in KRS. I have seen three Disneylands including the one in Tokyo, Japan, known as Disney World. Is the land available at KRS enough for an ambitious project like this? Is it safe to have a Disneyland under the menacing, intimidating massive dam with water gushing from its crest gates, specially during monsoon? It is as ridiculous as Modi saying he would make Mysuru like Paris. Irresponsible statement and we gullible people believe these utterances. The budget allocated for Kumaraswamy’s Disneyland is Rs. 5 crore. Impossible. But, a Kumaranna’s fan tells me it is only for preparing the Project Report. So be it.

Our city has an industrial area — Hebbal Industrial Area. As years pass, we find more and more residential colonies mushrooming here nudging out many industries considered polluting ones. Soon, we may need an Industrial Township Authority of Mysuru or Hebbal, taking the area out of MUDA, KIADB and Mysuru City Corporation. Has this government any solution for this problem?

If this kind of budget is presented in the future, Karnataka will face the danger of a split — as Old Mysuru and North Karnataka — just as the split of Andhra Pradesh, paradoxically a State that was the cause for the formation of the Linguistic States. We are warned.

e-mail: [email protected]

7 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Accidental Chief Minister must not present bogy budget”

  1. skywalker says:

    This CM’s budget is as you have indicated payback to the Gowda communities in : “Ramanagara, Mandya, Mysuru and Hassan for electing JD(S) candidates. Foolishly Poonacha then Kodagu CM enthusiastically supported Karnataka Ekikarana movement , fully knowing that his state will lose its separate identity. Since then Kodagu has become a non-entity in the eyes of Karnataka CMs. As for Old Mysuru and North Karnatak,a, the latter getting all the attention with Lingayat leaders hailing from there becoming prominent state leaders from the days, they were inducted into to form Karnataka, the patience may be wearing thin from voters of Old Mysuru, and the split like in Andhrapradesh, as you suggested will be inevitable.

  2. It is indeed true that Kodagu is neglected by all CMs of Karnataka. Kodgu does not even get 25% of the money the government showers on Bengaluru. I must also fault Mysuru and Kodagu MP Prata Sinha for devoting half his time to the welfare of citizens of Kodagu.

  3. Rahul says:

    SOM does not miss a chance to bash non-bjp at all.
    Not surprising!

  4. Ironically the budget by Chief minister H D Kumaraswamy seems to be presented only for widening the JD(S) vote bank.

    At the time of the formation of government, Kumaraswamy said that he would be the chief minister for all. But now, looking at the budget, it looks like he is the CM only for JD(S). He presented a budget favouring a few districts where JD(S) candidates won. He has taken a revenge on the undivided Dakshina Kannada and Coorg districts by not announcing a single project or programme for the regions strongly backing tge BJP. More needs to be said about the injustice done towards the rest of most parts of Karnataka.

    In a democracy, at the time of forming the government, numbers got more importanceand JD(S) and Congress got political power. Now the first priority of the Opposition should be to fight against the injustice faced by the coastal region and many other districts which is glaring and condemnable.

    Legislators cutting across party lines have a responsibility to speak on behalf of the people of all districts in the state. The type of injustice happening on the people towards the rest of the State is questionable.

    In this budget, giving farmers as a reason, Kumaraswamy has betrayed the people of other sections. He found an easy way to increase prices of petrol, diesel and electricity. During the formation of government, he had said that he will waive Rs 34,000 crore loan of farmers. But in the budget, he has kept only Rs 6,000 crore for it. From where will he bring the balance amount? Actually, without any planning and vision he has presented the budget.

    MLAs of ruling party also do not seem to be satisfied with the budget. Siddaramaiah and Parameshwara are already speaking a different tones over the budget. It indicates that this government will fall within a short period of time. Even Kumaraswamy himself does not seem to be confident about his term.

  5. dr.m.shanthakumar says:

    till this old budda h.d.devegowda dies nothing improves in our state. he is the most vulture person who is blocking our state progress. we must be careful next elections that this jds should be fully erased from the state.

    • Rahul says:

      pity for the hatredness that u vomit!
      Explain how H D Devegowda is blocking the progress of the state.
      What do u think is stopping Progress in other states of India?

  6. What a World! says:

    In the caste-riddled politics of Karanataka, where Gowdas and Lingayats held sway as leaders in the past decades, starting from Kengal in 1950s-a Gowda, then Nijalingappa and Jatti-Lingayats, no one gets surprised if a Gowda CM supports his communities in Mandya and Hassan which elected his candidates. North Karanataka is Lingayat’s citadel from where CMs like Jatti emerged, and gratefully showered goodies in that arid landmass. Nothing should surprise any one, now. Karnataka is a cesspit of opposing politics of Gowdas and Linagyats.


Mysuru’s favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 45 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it’s readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.


Academy News Papers Private Limited, Publishers, Star of Mysore & Mysuru Mithra, 15-C, Industrial ‘A’ Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru-570015. Phone no. – 0821 249 6520

To advertise on Star of Mysore, email us at

Online Edition: [email protected]
Print Editon: [email protected]
For News/Press Release: [email protected]