Do we need MLCs?
Columns, In Black & White, Top Stories

Do we need MLCs?

December 18, 2021

Election for Membership to the Karnataka Legislative Council (MLC) from Local Authorities’ Constituency concluded recently. Unfortunately, there was more talk of how much money candidates paid to get tickets and how much money they distributed to voters than talk of what each candidate would do if elected.

Many of us wonder, what does an MLC do after being elected? And what significance does a Legislative Council have in State governance? The answer is NOTHING. A Legislative Council serves no significant purpose, and it has to go. 

This bicameral system where the State’s Legislature has two houses — Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council — exists only in 6 States and Karnataka is one of them. When most States can function without a Council, why not Karnataka?

The Legislative Council also called ‘The House of Elders’ seems apt as it has no teeth; it simply has to swallow what it is fed with. When a Bill is put forth, the Council can only delay it for four months. After that, it will pass anyway. Similarly, when it comes to a Money Bill, the Council must return the Bill with a ‘pass’ within 14 days whether it likes it or not. Why then do we need this Council?

When describing the relevance of the Legislative Council in the State Legislature, many use the popular Kannada phrase, ‘Aatakkuntu Lekkakkilla,’ which translates to, ‘One may be in the game, but his presence does not count’.

The Legislative Council may be insignificant in the State Legislature, but its presence costs taxpayers’ money. And its members’ presence in urban bodies is negatively affecting everything, from urban planning to recruitment of teachers.

The truth is that the Council is not essential for administration but necessary for political parties as an ‘accommodation centre’ and ‘fund raiser’. Like the Raj Bhavan, the Legislative Council is also where political parties provide accommodation for party loyalists or members who could not be given MLA tickets.

It is also an opportunity to raise funds for the party as rich people pay to get an MLC ticket. And they pay because it is an investment — once an MLC, they get direct access to bureaucrats and Ministers through whom they can get their work done.

READ ALSO  Ladies, you got played... Mysuru in Trouble

Also, it is easier to win an MLC election than an MLA election as the voters for MLCs are very few, which makes it logistically manageable and financially viable. If you are willing to spend and of the right caste, it means your chances of winning are almost guaranteed.

The Election Commission does not have a cap on election expenditure for MLC elections like MLA, making it easy to bribe voters. According to reports in National dailies, most MLC voters were taking anywhere between Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 30,000 per vote! What has added to this high bribe amount is the preferential vote system. It drives up the prices as candidates want to get the first preferential vote to guarantee their win and do not want to risk being the second preference.

While political parties and a select few voters fill their treasuries, why are we taxpayers paying to maintain this Council?

The Legislative Council costs the taxpayer over Rs. 51 crore annually! Each MLC is given a car, phone allowance, health insurance, accommodation, and even Rs. 15 lakh for computers every year. The travel budget for Council members is Rs. 11 crore a year, that’s Rs. 14.6 lakh every year per MLC !

MLCs get Rs. 6 crore per year as Local Area Develop Fund which adds up to Rs. 36 crore for their six-year tenure! Interestingly there is no website where the public can see where and how this money is used. 

Once an MLC’s term is over, he and his family is eligible for a lifelong pension and health coverage. For all these benefits, what is their contribution to governance? Nothing.

Some say there is benefit to having a Legislative Council, citing that it is because of Rajya Sabha that we got people like Dr. Manmohan Singh and Arun Jaitley. But that may be so at the Centre. It is not the case in the State Upper House today.

READ ALSO  Pilot ejected, but Gandhis?

Indeed there was a time when we had leaders like S. Nijalingappa, Kadidal Manjappa and Khadri Shamanna in the Council. But today what do we have? We have tickets given to scrap dealers and real estate barons, most of whom made their money by being layout developers and builders. It’s no more the House of Elders. It is the house of builders.

The Council is called the ‘House of Elders’ as it is supposed to be filled with older and wise members. The nominated members are supposed to guide the Assembly as they are intelligent and worldly. The elected members are supposed to protect the interest of specific groups they represent, such as teachers, graduates and minority communities… But do they?

When have we ever seen an MLC from a teachers’ constituency speak about the minimum wage or training for teachers to make them future-ready? When have we seen an MLC talk about his vision for graduates, such as job creation, skill training? When have we heard an MLC talk about urban planning for their city? Never.

But they are in all the committees from MUDA to University recruitment. Is that why they become MLCs, to get first preference in allotments of corner sites, CA sites, stray sites, and vote on land approvals?

Undoubtedly the Legislative Council serves no significant purpose. It has become like the appendix in our abdomen. It serves no purpose to the body’s wellbeing but will cause harm when it ruptures. Similarly, the insignificance of the Council and the corruption of MLC elections prove that this appendix needs to be removed. But of course, why would any Government shut down its “accommodation centre.” Let’s hope some NGO takes up the cause.

e-mail: [email protected]

13 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Do we need MLCs?”

  1. Vipra says:

    Well thought out article

    You are sure to piss of many politicians but dont let that faze you !

  2. swamy says:

    Who will abolish just because you wrote an article? There should be Gokak like agitation to stop this, but common man will not show any interest about this. But kudos to you, toshine light on a matter that wastes State’s resources.

  3. Nandini says:

    Ignorance-based article.
    MLCs elected from teachers’ constituencies did wonderful work decades ago, when there were many issues related to for example, girls ‘education. The membership of the Legislative Council for the elected teachers gave them opportunities to asl questions to ministers and to get them to look into as for example, schools for girls, women only colleges, which MLAs were not interested, as these issues. MLAs then and now were/are interested in how much they can get as Baksheesh ( bribe) to fight for a cause.
    One example of a MLC who was elected from teachers’ constituency was Professor MPL Shastry, in Bengaluru, who pioneered education for girls , established the MES Society which supported such causes, getting government grants by raising issues in the Legislative Council, which would not have been possible without his MLC status. He persuaded ministers and the CM at that time, to get grant to provide techer’s training for women free of cost for those who were subjected to abuse from their families, and this enabled both these women and those who were poor to get trainied for teachers in primary and middle schools as well as in high schools.
    Legislative council in states are like Rajya Sabha, a part of the bi-cameral legislature that Indian constitution mandated. It enabled those who had special expertise and skills to get inducted as members, and many times serve the government as ministers.
    It is not very surprising that the editor Vikram is so glib and dismissive.

  4. boregowda says:

    But alas those days of public service and public servants are over. The present day MLC bandicoots are here for ripping us off.

  5. Gusto says:

    @boregowda
    Legislative Councils are part of the Legislature in states created by your constitution.
    Whenever I visit India-these days not much, I see the society being very corrupt, very dishonest and I think with that kind of society, you deserve the same kind of politicians-MLAs, MLCs or ministers Every India who visits here, in a Western country, could do so because, he is laundering the bribe money.

  6. Thimmaiah says:

    Totally in agreement. This whole process is an incubation center for corruption. Nepotism also flourishes through this. Case in point is MCA’s brother became MLC in Kodagu; the third brother is already an MLC. The new MLC has reputation of being a goon and it is a disappointing situation in the modern civilized world.

  7. Questo says:

    The goal of the council is to delay the passing of the bills which it deems to be flawed. This gives room for public discussion, pressure campaigns to change/withdraw the bills, draw attention to the issues in the bill, etc. Unfortunately, the council may have not been doing any of that.

  8. Ganesh Nerale says:

    Nice article. Measuring the performance of our leaders through monetary gains to society is need of the hour. If we are spending in crores (election cost + salary) and benefiting in thousands then its waste of public money. Please raise this issue and divert that money to pay teachers and improve education system.

  9. Garadi Mane Questo says:

    The goal of the Council is to scrutinise the Bill. The founding fathers of the Indian constitution wanted this to be a chamber where the wise men/women who came through other constituencies not represented by the Assembly to give direction.
    This bicameral approach at the state and central level was copied from US and Europe (UK) particularly.

  10. Never Presto Questo says:

    @Questo as usual talks nonsense. May be he posted his after a long work out on the tread mill, in a ‘technology ‘savvy’ basement atmosphere , followed by a strong black coffee!
    Legislative Councils are part of the bicameral legislature set up one sees in the US ( except Nebraska). The purpose is to provide checks and balances to the other chamber. The Indian constitution fathers, particularly Sir Alladi, an eminent lawyer, customised this concept to suit to India.
    The ‘delay’ is not the right word, but ‘ revision through scrutiny’ are, as those MLCs who have specialist knowledge through the scrutiny process of wider consultation have the opportunity to improve a bill through revision/s.

  11. vishnu bhat says:

    with a Govt like ours, do we need a Govt at all?

  12. Never Presto Questo says:

    @vishnu
    Mysoreans ( Indians) deserve the government that you have now and before.
    No Mysorean/Indian is honest, and the sopciety is totally corupt so too the institutions and politicians, You deserve them.
    Even Lord Vishnu cannot help you.

  13. Never Presto Questo says:

    @vishnu
    Mysoreans ( Indians) deserve the government that you have now and before.
    No Mysorean/Indian is honest, and the society is totally corupt so too the institutions and politicians, You deserve them.
    Even Lord Vishnu cannot help you.

ABOUT

Mysuru’s favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 41 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it’s readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.

CONTACT

Academy News Papers Private Limited, Publishers, Star of Mysore & Mysuru Mithra, 15-C, Industrial ‘A’ Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru-570015. Phone no. – 0821 249 6520

To advertise on Star of Mysore, email us at

Online Edition: [email protected]
Print Editon: [email protected]
For News/Press Release: [email protected]