J.B.S. Haldane: Distinguished yet Disillusioned!
Columns, Over A Cup of Evening Tea

J.B.S. Haldane: Distinguished yet Disillusioned!

November 20, 2022

By Dr. K. Javeed Nayeem, MD

Last weekend, I wrote about how I received a wrong book in response to my order from an online bookseller and how, instead of being a complete disappointment, it turned out to be an event with an unexpectedly interesting ending.

As I have already said, the wrong book that I received was a biography of the famous scientist J.B.S. Haldane, entitled ‘A Dominant Character’ by Samanth Srinivasan, a London based writer of Indian origin. Yes, I think mentioning his Indian origin is very necessary here today because we Indians are by now much used to revel in the sense of satisfaction and even accomplishment that the term connotes and brings us and conveys to others!

The book is not just highly informative but very readable and enjoyable too, with never a dull page or passage. And, the author who, as I have already credited as being a very capable and captivating writer, perhaps could not have chosen a better and more apt title for his book, considering the fact that after you read it, you simply cannot disagree that its protagonist would deserve any other phrase to describe his unique personality. But, at least to me, Haldane comes across as an extremely intelligent genius, who was naturally not bereft of the extreme eccentricity that is said to always accompany extreme intellect!

The man was a political party worker, fighting soldier, mathematician, statistician, chemist, physicist and biologist, all rolled into one. As a man wearing many hats in the field of biology, he dabbled in physiology, genetics, medicine and evolutionary studies and most surprisingly he excelled in everything he did and thus made a mark in the world of science, although the only degree he held was in mathematics alone.

Yes, with absolutely no academic qualifications in any of the biological sciences, he not only launched himself into biological research but also held very high and enviable academic positions. Thankfully, he was from a time and a place where the only attribute that mattered for a man to make a mark, was whether what he was talking, made sense or not!

Samanth Subramanian

There have been many such others, in the field of science, arts, philosophy and politics, who found their deserved and desired niches, without any matching academic qualifications and who yet managed to leave their marks on history, indelibly. Haldane had some very strong political views too because of which he had a very turbulent life, which finally resulted in him relinquishing his British citizenship and deciding to settle down in India.

So, in the year 1957 when he was sixty-five-years-old, he boarded an Air India flight and flew down from London to Calcutta, where he took up a professional assignment at the Indian Statistical Institute (ISI). The precipitating factor that nudged him to do this was his sense of outrage and utter disgust when the United Kingdom, France and Israel attacked Egypt in a joint bid to take control of the strategic Suez Canal, which he saw as a very wrong act. In an interview with The Times, just before departing from Britain, he said “I do not want to be a citizen here any longer, because Britain is a criminal State.” And, in his official resignation letter, submitted to his University, he wrote, “I no longer want to be a subject of a State which has been found guilty of aggression by the overwhelming verdict of the human race. I believe that I shall find in India, opportunities for research and teaching in a country whose government, by its active work for peace, gives an example to the world.” Very touching words indeed, for any Indian like me!

READ ALSO  A Noble Soul on a Noble Mission!

India had attracted him when he attended the Indian Science Congress in Calcutta in the year 1954 and toured the country, delivering thirty-five lectures in a span of just seven weeks. During this trip he became a close friend of P. C. Mahalanobis, the Director of the ISI, at whose house he had stayed too and upon whose invitation he agreed to join the institute as a scientist.

But restless and unaccommodating that he was, his honeymoon with the ISI too was very short lived, just like his first marriage to Charlotte Franken and he walked away from there, disappointed with his working relationship with his friend, the Director! He shifted base to Bhubaneshwar in Orissa on the invitation of Biju Patnaik, the Chief Minister there, who recognising his worth, offered to establish for him an institute of genetics and biochemistry.

However, his remaining life was too short for him to do anything worthwhile and during a visit to the US for a scientific seminar, he fell sick with profuse rectal bleeding. On his way back to India he stopped over at London where the reason for his problem was diagnosed as rectal cancer for which he underwent surgery there. But his cancer eluded a complete cure and he went into many complications to which he succumbed on 1st, December, 1964.

Even close to his death, his wry sense of humour did not leave him. When his second wife Helen Spurway, in the presence of a few of his students, handed him the letter written by his doctor from Calcutta, informing him about the incurability of his disease, he told her that she should have taken his pulse before and after he read it, to check how unperturbed he was! He said that while he was not afraid of exiting from this world, he was only scared of exiting from it with unkept promises. He had these words from the Bhagavadgita for his students who were standing around him:

Jaatasya hi dhruvo mrtyuh

Druvam janma mrtasya ca

Tasmad apariharya ‘rthe

Na tvam socitum arhasi

(For one who has taken birth, death is certain, For one who is dead, birth is certain. Therefore, for what is inevitable, Do not grieve.)

READ ALSO  Time for a little more patience!

Soon after the diagnosis of his ailment was made too, he wrote a poem about cancer which I shall reproduce here later. Haldane had willed that his body, after his death, should be used for scientific study and it was therefore shifted to the Rangaraya Medical College at Kakinada in the neighbouring State of Andhra Pradesh, for dissection and preservation of the organs. After that was done, the tiny bones from his ears were sent to the University of Chicago, while the rest of his skeleton was bleached and strung up for display in the anatomy museum, where it still stands to this day.

Till I myself entered medical college, as a first-year medical student, in the year 1975, I knew nothing about this unusual man of science. It is from this moment of the death of this colossus of science that a very important link got established between the man who dissected the body of Haldane to study and preserve it and who, a full decade later, walked into our classroom as our first teacher, for the very first class of our medical career.

This colossus was Dr. Vissa Ramachandra Rao, who soon after his retirement from service at the Rangaraya Medical College, joined the M. R. Medical College, Gulbarga, as the Professor and Head of the Department of Anatomy. Very quickly into my first year, he somehow developed a strong liking for me and the very important reason for this was perhaps the great interest we both had in photography, reading and the history of medicine.

Apart from teaching us Anatomy, he used to hold slide shows at his house and tell us all about his travels across the world and his long stint in Britain. It was during one of these sessions that he told us about how he had dissected and preserved the body of J.B.S. Haldane, the scientist. While he had shown us slides of his work and Haldane’s strung-up skeleton, I could never find a single picture of it even on the internet and sadly in the short time that I had, to write this series of articles, I could not contact anyone at the Rangaraya Medical College, who could have helped me by sending me some pictures that I could have used here. Hopefully, I’ll be able to visit the place some time and do it myself.

To go back a little and brush up the memory of my regular readers, I would like to mention here that way back in the year 2012, after I had gone to see my guru, Dr. V. R. R. Rao, in Salem, where he was living in retirement, as a nonagenarian, I had written about his role in preserving the mortal remains of Haldane, the scientist of international repute. For those who do not know what I am talking about, there’s always time and occasion for it next week!

e-mail: [email protected]

6 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “J.B.S. Haldane: Distinguished yet Disillusioned!”

  1. Gautam says:

    What a load of observations which do not make much sense, except that he wants the attention to focus on himself: Javeed Nayeem, the scholar extraordinaire1 The man is full of vanity.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Have you noticed how he calls himself an MD. In India and UK doctors don’t call them MDs. They have MBBS after their name. Only in US and may be in Canada, doctors use MD after their name. You may be right, this man is vain!!

  3. vipra says:

    MD stands for Doctor of Medicine
    In a world where fake doctorates can be had for money and people flaunt their honorary doctortates by insisting to be addressesd as “Doctor ”
    use of MD by a physician is not unreasonable

  4. Gautam says:

    @Anonymous
    In the US, the first medical degree and the only medical degree is MD-which is obtained after 5-6 years after an undergraduate degree. If one wants to specialise in a particular branch of medicine, one has to get qualified as board -certified specialist, after training and sitting in exams.
    In India the MD is a degree obtained after MBBS by attending a regular course. It is a university postgraduate degree.
    In the UK , after MBBS, one could obtain MD through a topic research in medicine .under a mentor But it is a research degree. The UK has other postgraduate certificate specialist qualifications such as MRCP .FRCS -administered by Royal Colleges in Medicine and Surgery, independent organisations, which are obtained after working under a mentor and getting trained-just like board certification in the US.
    These days in India, it is not enough to have MD, but one has to get trained and national board certified too-it is called DNB after MD, just like in the US.
    In the case of Javeed Nayeem, he got his MD in the University of Mysore, under a professor called Dr Jadhav, the chief physician in the KR Hospital, who was after massive amount of money whether it is patients or students, and money hence bought MD under him.
    No one rated a MD gained under Jadhav, and in the University of Mysore. Money always played its part, considering Dr Jadhav ‘s greed for cash!
    But my doubt is Nayeem visited the UK, as a tourist, but as a medical tourist to get treatment for his cardiac ailment. The JBS Haldane book is a distraction to mask this.
    It is easy if your relative you visit is also a doctor in the UK. After 2/3 days of stay with your relative, your relative the doctor will call the hospital , saying his visitor has developed heart problem which needs hospitalisation. The UK emergency laws allow the visitor to get treated free at a major hospital. Job done for free! That isa loop hole in the UK, which is difficult to plug. The demand for medical insurance does not always work, if a visitor develops severe heart problem, when a treatment is necessary quickly.
    Javeed Nayeem always consider himself as a scholar of eminence, although there is no evidence to prove it. Hence, a Vain man.

  5. Bengaluru Loknath says:

    Javeed Nayeem has the propensity to do his research inadequate to get at the root of the issue.
    JBS Haldane, was a Marxist, and was highly political , focusing mostly on politics and not his scientific research.
    Hence, his achievements though looks impressive for Javeed Nayeem who knows nothing about genetics, was modest by international standards.
    This is what makes Nayeem a shallow columnist.
    Haldane was invited by Nehru, and was attached to the Indian Statistical Institute, hoping that he would develop a new band of Indian scientists. Haldane did nothing of the kind. Although he acquired Indian citizenship, he still retained British citizenship as Britain alllowed ( still allows) dual nationalities.
    For the information of Nayeem,, Haldane never settled in India, was always visiting his native Britain and travelling around the world. At hat time , many questioned Nehru’s judgement about Haldane. After his colon cancer surgery in London, Haldane was down hiill and died without contributing much.
    His research on genetics is totally outdated now, as the Human Genome Project has taken the genetic research in a new direction. The Pfizer Covid Vaccine is an example of this new direction .
    For the information of Nayeem, Nehru also invited the German aeronautical engineer Kurt Tank who was working in Egypt then, Kurt Tank was attached to HAL: to develop the next generation jet fighter. That fizzled out the same way as Haldane reseARCH.
    Haldane is only of interest to Lefties like Samanth Subramanian, who lives in London and contributes to left-leaning publications.
    A lot of hot air here and no light!

  6. vijay anand says:

    Nice read on medical history for intresting trivia. Might have historical inaccuracies, but do keep writing , rest will be corrected by the critics to get the wholesome for readers, else nothing to start with….

ABOUT

Mysuru’s favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 41 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it’s readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.

CONTACT

Academy News Papers Private Limited, Publishers, Star of Mysore & Mysuru Mithra, 15-C, Industrial ‘A’ Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru-570015. Phone no. – 0821 249 6520

To advertise on Star of Mysore, email us at

Online Edition: [email protected]
Print Editon: [email protected]
For News/Press Release: [email protected]