Musings on Dr. S.L. Bhyrappa’s defence of CAA —1
Abracadabra By K. B. Ganapathy, Columns

Musings on Dr. S.L. Bhyrappa’s defence of CAA —1

January 13, 2020

The sea is dangerous and its storms terrible, but these obstacles have never been sufficient reason to remain ashore.”

— Ferdinand Magellan, Portuguese explorer (1480-1521)

For those who are opposing CAA in our country today, the idea of India is not in believing ‘India first.’ For them, India seems to come next. Whatever it is, I cannot but remember the architect of our Constitution Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, whose pronouncements have become prophetic when we study the present political situation. In his book “Thoughts on Pakistan”, the main refrain was division of India into Hindustan and Pakistan on the presumption that it would bring prosperity, peace and salvation to Hindus. So also for Muslims who wanted a separate religion-based Muslim country — Pakistan

Dr. S.L. Bhyrappa, the renowned Kannada novelist and a philosopher in his own right, is not only a household name in every educated Kannada home but also among those who are given to reading books. After all, most of his novels and other original writings (24 novels and four volumes of literary criticism and books on aesthetics, social issues and culture) have been translated to many Indian and foreign languages.

He lives in our city and occasionally expresses views on issues that concern our society and country. Apparently, looking at the relentless, sometimes violent, agitations by the opposition parties led by Congress against the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), he must have felt like Ferdinand Magellan quoted above and called the media to defend the CAA. Dr. Bhyrappa was not ready to remain silent in the face of these protests against a good law made for the good of our country.

Ever since India became independent in 1947, it was the Indian National Congress (which was in the forefront of the Indian Independence Movement) that captured power in the electoral politics and ruled this country continuously for over six decades with brief interregnums.

In times of political difficulties, Congress heavily leaned on the left political parties and communal parties like Muslim League for survival, both at the Centre and States. Seeing this kind of political agenda of the Congress party, Dr. Bhyrappa said in his press meet on last Friday, January 10, 2020 that “the Congress was adopting the divide and rule policy of                                                                     the British who had created a rift between Hindus and Muslims during the freedom struggle.” Surely, Dr. Bhyrappa was not saying anything new. However, it is important for the present day Hindus of India to remember what Dr. Bhyrappa said next.

READ ALSO  POINT BLANK: Is the State BJP falling apart?

He accused Jawaharlal Nehru, our first Prime Minister of the Congress, of dividing Hindu society on caste basis in order to consolidate Muslim votes as a guaranteed vote bank. Dr. Bhyrappa, therefore, goes hammer and tongs against Congress and the opposition parties who are now relentlessly engaged in organising protest – demonstrations, many times violent, against the enactment of CAA, which was passed with a comfortable majority both in the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha in the spirit of democracy and our Constitution which the opposition parties claim to hold in highest esteem, some even calling it their only holy book.

If the Government has not violated either the Constitution or the principles of democracy in bringing this law, CAA, what is the problem for the Congress and the opposition parties in supporting it? Apparently, the enactment of CAA has rattled the Congress and the left parties politically. Therefore, Dr. Bhyrappa said they were indulging in the current agitation across the country.

All things considered, it is not surprising that at the Congress Working Committee’s (CWC) first meeting in 2020, its President Sonia Gandhi has said, “The sinister purpose of the law is clear to every patriotic, tolerant and secular Indian: It is to divide the Indian people on religious lines.” (The Hindu, 12.1.2020). Now, will someone please tell the Congress President Sonia Gandhi, who came to India after decades of independence, that the Indian people were divided on religious lines in 1947 and  the Congress party was primarily responsible for it?

READ ALSO  Lalitha Mahal Palace Hotel and an old memory...

The Congress and the Opposition parties should also introspect about the reason why the need for CAA arose. Certainly, they are aware of it. So also our Parliament members who otherwise would not have passed the law with such clear majority. Dr. Bhyrappa has spoken about illegal immigrants entering Assam and West Bengal since partition in 1947 and how the Congress was using these immigrants as vote bank even after 1971 war.

Therefore, it is beyond reason and logic to oppose the CAA meant to deal with the illegal immigrants, the helpless minority non-muslim communities, from three Muslim majority non-secular (theocratic) countries who are our neighbours, namely Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan. The Congress (UPA) and the                                                      opposition parties are demanding the repeal of CAA and opposing the National Population Register (NPR) as well as the National Register of Citizens (NRC) at the cost of country’s security and development.

Worst scenario is the one where over a hundred former top bureaucrats said there was an “undue obsession” about the illegal immigrants which is causing ”deep unease” among Muslims.  Well, are they talking about Pakistan Muslims or our Indian Muslims? Please clarify. It is anybody’s guess who these bureaucrats were serving while in Government service — the Congress party or the country! They must realise that the Indian Constitution is for Indians of all faiths, Muslims in India included, but not for the Muslims who are illegal immigrants.

For those who are opposing CAA in our country today, the idea of India is not in believing ‘India first.’ For them, India seems to come next. Whatever it is, I cannot but remember the architect of our Constitution Dr. B.R. Ambedkar at this juncture. Dr. Ambedkar was a visionary whose pronouncements have become prophetic when we study the present political situation in our country. His book “Thoughts on Pakistan” published in 1940 was considered a magnum opus. The main refrain of the book was the division of India into Hindustan and Pakistan on the presumption that it would bring prosperity, peace and salvation to the Hindus. Of course, so also for Muslims who wanted a separate religion-based Muslim country Pakistan.

[To be continued]

e-mail: [email protected]

6 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Musings on Dr. S.L. Bhyrappa’s defence of CAA —1”

  1. boregowda says:

    Amen, well said sir.

  2. What a culture! says:

    Byrappa is talking nonsense about British creating the division of Hindus and Muslims, when that division existed even before British arrived in India. The wars between Rajputs and Mughals was a war between the Muslim rulers exercising the hegemony on Hindu rulers. It is easy to accuse someone else, who were in India 70+ years ago, for the current situation created by the 2 Gujarathis in power: Modi and Shah, by enacting a dubious Act. When Gandhi suggested Jinnah as the PM of undivided India, it was unpalatable not only to Jinnah but to many Congress leaders too. Patel , disagreed with it and agreed that the partition was the only solution.

    Byrappa also says: “Therefore, it is beyond reason and logic to oppose the CAA meant to deal with the illegal immigrants, the helpless minority non-muslim communities, from three Muslim majority non-secular (theocratic) countries who are our neighbours, namely Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan”, Then why call it CAA instead of Legal Immigrant Citizenship Act for example, which makes the purpose very clear.
    As for the Act sailing through both Houses of Parliament, any government with a hefty majority can achieve it easily. It does not mean the Act is fit for the purpose or there is no hidden agenda.

  3. Strangeworld says:

    @Whataculture.. Neither Bhyrappa nor Modi Sonia or Rahul is a nonsense! You are the only mentally retarded and biggest arrogant nonsense in the block ! You think you know everything? That is what every idiot thinks! And you are theit king! Please look in to the mirror and you will see the biggest idiot in the world reading your comments, you are one pathetic looser who has nothing in life but to criticize everything I can’t understand what is the necessity of such low life like you to this world ,

  4. Nikhil Gowda says:

    @What a culture! You think Bhyrappa is talking nonsense? He is one of the most progressive writer’s whose books are sold out on day one! And you moron think that he is nonsense! How many books you have written? Have you written anything other than the SOM readers comments? And you got all your wisdom from licking some Congressi corrupt ass?I know you m7st be some coding ex coolie who failed in your miserable job and life after kicked out of US and you have developed caustic hatred towards everybody who is successful! Your presence only indicates that mysore corporation dog catchers are not efficient in catching rabid dogs like you!

  5. Rahul says:

    Nobody explained CAA never then Sadguru !
    Why are you protesting against CAA? .. i may be deported as I don’t have any document
    Do you have Birth cirtificate!? No I don’t have
    Any proof from school or college? I NEVER went to school
    Any employment! No I never worked
    Any driver license!? No I never had it
    Any addresses what you stayed, ration card or bank detailed any proof .. I don’t have
    At least do you know 3 people who can vouch that you were here in this country.? No I don’t have any
    THEN Who the bell at you? WHAT THE HELL YOU ARE DOING HERE.
    Guess what! These scumbags were protesting in Mangalore throwing stones at police! Police dragged then to police station! All three goons produced all their idetitity details, like Drivers license, address, lawyers who came to police station to identify them, property record’s, bank a count details and bail money to bail them !
    This is the manufactured protest were at seeing!

  6. What a culture! says:

    @Nikhil Gowda. Spoken like a Gowda, an uncivilised member of a mob who come up in life based on their caste! I am not an IT coolie, and am very successful professionally and unlike you my contributions are wide scientifically and technologically. I never consider a Gowda, an intellectual person and that shows in your uncivilised language, typical indeed. It is very ignorant to ridicule any one who is against the ill-thought out policy like the CAA, which is meant to address a specific issue. Interesting that It does not have a different name,
    @strangeworld, you must be another vile Indian who has no manners or civilised behaviour.
    I always thought that the current generation of Indians are thick and ill-educated and follow leaders like sheep. Modi is well aware of this!!

ABOUT

Mysuru’s favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 41 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it’s readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.

Recent Comments
CONTACT

Academy News Papers Private Limited, Publishers, Star of Mysore & Mysuru Mithra, 15-C, Industrial ‘A’ Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru-570015. Phone no. – 0821 249 6520

To advertise on Star of Mysore, email us at

Online Edition: [email protected]
Print Editon: [email protected]
For News/Press Release: [email protected]