Right to Recall MPs, MLAs will curb corruption
Abracadabra By K. B. Ganapathy, Columns, Top Stories

Right to Recall MPs, MLAs will curb corruption

March 7, 2023

This is the time to remember and reiterate the view of Jayaprakash Narayan (JP), revered as Lok Nayak, that the people have the right to demand resignation of their elected representatives if they fail in their duty and become corrupt, autocratic and inefficient. If they do not resign — MLAs, MLCs and MPs who work for private gain and not for public good — they must be recalled. This is called the ‘Right To Recall’ (RTR).

The principle behind this idea is that the Right to Elect MUST accompany the Right to Recall because whenever elected representative violates the legal and moral code of conduct he can be Recalled if he does not resign on his own.

It is argued that if the Right to Recall is denied to the voter, Democracy shall become a mockery. And sadly today it has. It is because our Constitution does not provide for the Right to Recall. If only it had, this Right to Elect of the voter would have made the MPs and MLAs accountable to the voters.

However, some States under their powers to legislate on State Subjects have passed Recall Laws at Municipal and Local Bodies level. Among them are MP, Chhattisgarh and even Bihar. Not in our State!

As years passed by, after Independence, our Democracy became a ‘functioning anarchy’ as Prof. John Kenneth Galbraith had famously said as long ago as 1960s. At last, a Constitution (Amendment) Bill about Voter’s Right to Recall MPs and MLAs was introduced in the Lok Sabha in 1974 (a year before the infamous Emergency was declared) but the Bill did not pass.

It is important to note that Atal Bihari Vajpayee of Jana Sangh (now BJP) had supported this Bill. Well, it is a paradox that this Bill was never followed up by NDA under Vajpayee when it came to power later nor by the UPA led by Congress. For reasons best known to itself, the then Election Commission had opposed the Bill for Right to Recall. According to reports, BJP MP Varun Gandhi had introduced, surprisingly, a Private Member’s Bill, The Representation of the People (Amendment) Bill in 2016 when NDA (BJP) was in power with Narendra Modi as Prime Minister. Whatever happened to its fate GoK. However, we know whatever happened to Varun Gandhi through the social media. Let it be.

When the Janata Party led by JP came to power at the Centre, after the Emergency, in 1977, JP wanted the new Government to bring laws regarding the Right to Recall and to create a designated legal authority, like the High Court and Supreme Court, to deal expeditiously with the cases of corruption. Looking at what is happening today with regard to rampant corruption found among elected representatives, it is obvious no political party, including BJP whose Prime Minister Narendra Modi in great rhetoric declared from every corner of the country that ‘Na khaunga na khane dunga’ (neither will I take bribe nor will I allow others to take bribe), wants to bring the Law about Right to Recall. True Modi by himself is a Paragon of Virtue. But what is hindering him from taking the advice of JP? Or take forward the 2016 Bill of Varun Gandhi? These are pertinent questions asked by the young, intelligent and old, wise voters of this country.

READ ALSO  Dr. CPK releases book on Kodavas

These idealistic, intelligent young people and the wise, enlightened senior voters are the millions of Arjunas in the electoral Kurukshetra of Indian Democracy. Narendra Modi, the Prime Minister, is the Krishna leading these millions of Arjunas in this war. And what does the last chapter of the Bhagavadgita, say?

Wherever Krsna, the master of yoga, and the archer Partha are present, there will always be good fortune, victory, wealth, well-being and righteousness. This is my conviction. [Ch.18]

Where there is Arjuna the Warrior and Krishna the Divinity, there is always Victory. Have no doubts. And here for one Krishna (Modi) there are crores of Arjunas (Indian voters). Therefore, now is the time for Modi to fulfill the aspirations of JP.

An elderly voter came to meet me yesterday afternoon, presented me a bunch of fresh, beautiful, blood-red, long-stemmed roses and a tastefully wrapped packet of sweets to discuss a “very serious matter.” He had come armed with a piece of paper wherein was scribbled his “serious matter” or problem. Going by my long experience as a journalist, I thought it must be his personal problem. I was indeed foxed by this old fox of an honest citizen of India. He was not foxy though.

Mentioning that the State Assembly election is at our threshold and reminding me of the Rs. 8 crore cash seized in a corruption case involving an MLA and his bureaucrat son, this visitor asked me to take the lead to form a Watchdog Committee to create voter awareness about voting for an honest, meritorious candidate who would work for public good and not for private, personal gain (by indulging in corruption). He also wanted the ‘Voter Awareness Committee’ to act as an informer to the Lokayukta to catch the corrupt public and government servants.

READ ALSO  Geeth Gaatha Chal Musical Nite by Doctors enthrals audience

He wanted a Law to be made to forfeit the cash, jewellery, even immovable and movable properties illegally acquired and seized by the authorities, Lokayukta, IT, ED or CBI to be taken over by the Government if the accused is not able to give proper, convincing explanation or provide documents to claim them to be legally acquired within 10 days after the raid and seizure.

He also wanted a Right to Recall Law to be passed by the Parliament and that I should write about it. Well, with roses lying on my table, so pleasing to my eyes and freshening my breath with its subtle fragrance while that sweet packet tempting me to open it and taste its contents, how can I say no to this noble, patriotic old soul sitting in front of me. Helpless,  I was to help him.

He must have read my face like a physiognomist and said, “…but the journey of a thousand mile, like that of Rahul Gandhi’s (smiles gently with a twinkle in his somnolent eyes), starts with the first step. You start, we will follow.” That was a tall order. He even quoted Swami Vivekananda — Arise, awake, and stop not till the  goal is reached.

Later, I  called  Bhamy V. Shenoy of MGP the local NGO to take up the cause. As for me, I have kept my promise by writing this article on the lines that senior citizen had wanted. My call: Voters of India unite, you have nothing to lose but your corrupt MPs and MLAs.

e-mail: [email protected]

4 COMMENTS ON THIS POST To “Right to Recall MPs, MLAs will curb corruption”

  1. Gautam says:

    These days, when I read Mr Ganapathy’s column, I cannot help thinking that it is time for Mr Ganapathy to retire gracefully, enjoy the ride in his shiny Mercedes, and take travelling visiting national and foreign places to burn his cash.
    Mr Ganapathy has come up with his ideaof Pandavas -BJP and Kauravas-Congress and other parties.
    He has identified his Krishna-Narendra Modi and the Arjunas-the other leaders in the BJP..
    Let us examine these Arjunas.
    Krishna’s -Narendra Modi’s Arjunas in Karnataka: Arjunas Bommai and Yedi, with Bommai accused of presiding over 40% commission government, and Yedi facing corruption probe.
    Mr Ganaoathy cannot bring himself up to say that those bundles of Rupees piled up high, were discovered in the home linked to one of Yadava’s-the followers of Krihn. The Yadava here is a BJP MLA!
    With the BJP in power , the only places where these bundles of cash could be found are in Yadavas’ homes. This Yadava-the BJP MLA, seems to be a small fish, and yet the cash discovered was in crores. If Congress comes to power, and they raid the houses of Krishna’s prominent Yadavas- BJP MPs, they will discover mountains of cash worth tens of crores of Rupees!
    Krishna- Modi accused Congress of 10% government, but one of his Arjuna s-Bommai runs a 40% government now!
    Krishna- Modi accused Gandhis of dynastic rule, but he demands that his brother Prahlad’s family who met with a minor accident, to be treated as VIPs. His chief Arjuna , Amit Shah has a son called Jay Shah, is literally ruling the state of Gujarat, not even elected as a MLA there!
    So, Mr Ganapathy’s recall advice is implemented, almost all MLAs and MPs that belong to the Yadava community-the BJP will be recalled, plus perhaps a few from other parties, as those parties are weaker these days, and do not rule many states.
    Again, Mr Ganapathy must be losing his marbles, by asking Barmy Shenoy and his Grahachara outfit of retirees to take up the cause. as he must have not read in his own SOM news that the stunt of Satyagrahara day Barmy Shenoy proposed and executed on a Sunday recently in Mysore, was sparsely attended; his howls of saving Chamudi Hill from developments echoed in the parks that day, became a futile energy loss, as CM Bommai allocated in his recent budget, crores of Rupees for the tourism development of the Hill! That was a slap in the face of Barmy Shenoy’s Satyagraha!
    Putting fail on lackeys like Barmy Shenoy and his Grahachara outfit of retirees sounds like a massive hallucination that says more about Mr Ganapathy these days!

  2. Vijay says:

    BJP has showcased itself in a very poor manner in this whole episode. If BJP doesn’t go behind it’s own legislators who are corrupt then it will be indirectly encouraging them towards corruption. When BJP MPs and MLA have belief that CBI, IT or ED would never come chasing them, then they would be further embolden to indulge in corruption. BJP used to blame Manmohan Singh that though he was clean but he allowed scams to happen under his watch. The same thing is now happening under PM Modi’s regime. Today BJP has the highest number of MPs and MLA among all parties. Do they really think people are naive enough to believe that not a single person from their party is corrupt?

  3. Questo says:

    In which category of Mahabharata men would Mr Ganapathy place MP Simha? Dhushyasana, I guess, as Simha behaves autocratically with arrogance. Only Dhushyasana has that kind of wicked arrogance!

  4. Shyam says:

    Much of the comments in this news paper can he explained very well in this video
    https://youtu.be/irSdmPFeYUU

ABOUT

Mysuru’s favorite and largest circulated English evening daily has kept the citizens of Mysuru informed and entertained since 1978. Over the past 45 years, Star of Mysore has been the newspaper that Mysureans reach for every evening to know about the happenings in Mysuru city. The newspaper has feature rich articles and dedicated pages targeted at readers across the demographic spectrum of Mysuru city. With a readership of over 2,50,000 Star of Mysore has been the best connection between it’s readers and their leaders; between advertisers and customers; between Mysuru and Mysureans.

CONTACT

Academy News Papers Private Limited, Publishers, Star of Mysore & Mysuru Mithra, 15-C, Industrial ‘A’ Layout, Bannimantap, Mysuru-570015. Phone no. – 0821 249 6520

To advertise on Star of Mysore, email us at

Online Edition: [email protected]
Print Editon: [email protected]
For News/Press Release: [email protected]